MAMDANI STANDS BY CONTROVERSIAL OCTOBER 7 POST: Mayor Rejects Calls to Separate Hamas Massacre Remembrance From Israel Criticism
Gallery
Videos
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani is facing renewed criticism after refusing to reconsider his controversial October 7 anniversary statement during a heated exchange at the New York Times DealBook Summit on November 18. Moderator Andrew Ross Sorkin directly challenged the mayor, asking why he could not dedicate one day exclusively to remembering the approximately 1,200 people murdered by Hamas during the October 7, 2023, terrorist attacks before criticizing Israel's military response in Gaza. The question drew applause from members of the audience, putting Mamdani under pressure to explain why his anniversary message combined mourning for Israeli victims with accusations against the Israeli government. Mamdani defended his approach, saying he had attended a vigil honoring those killed on October 7 and arguing that there must be room to mourn everyone affected by the conflict. He also repeated his accusation that Israel is committing genocide in Gaza, claiming the October 7 attacks have been used to justify everything that followed. Rather than agreeing to separate the two subjects, Mamdani declared that his position reflects a “politics of universality,” insisting that he would continue applying the same principles to Israelis and Palestinians.
The confrontation revived controversy surrounding Mamdani's October 7 statement, which briefly condemned Hamas' attack as a horrific war crime but devoted much of its message to condemning Israel's military campaign in Gaza. Jewish organizations and community leaders criticized the timing and emphasis, arguing that the anniversary of the massacre should have allowed Israeli victims and their families to be remembered without immediately turning the occasion into an indictment of Israel. During the summit, Sorkin also raised concerns about the mayor's responsibility to consider how his language affects Jewish New Yorkers, particularly amid concerns over antisemitism in the city. Mamdani responded that he was proud to serve as mayor of what he called the most Jewish city in the United States and pledged to oppose antisemitism and all forms of bigotry. However, he made clear that he would not change his approach to discussing October 7 and the war in Gaza. The exchange highlights the continuing divide over how political leaders should commemorate the Hamas massacre while addressing the devastating consequences of the subsequent war.