Two Suspects Busted After Brazen $45,000 Pokémon and Magic Card Smash-and-Grab in Cary, NC — Cops Recover Most of the Stolen Loot in Rapid Arrest

Cary, North Carolina police moved fast and moved decisively, arresting two suspects — 20-year-old James Fillingame and a 17-year-old juvenile — after the pair carried out a brazen smash-and-grab robbery at Triangle Area Trading Cards in the early morning hours of May 2026, making off with approximately $45,000 worth of Pokémon and Magic: The Gathering cards before officers tracked them down and recovered most of the stolen merchandise. The thieves smashed through a store window in the dead of night, quickly bagging high-value cards from display cases in what appeared to be a targeted, premeditated strike on one of the area's most well-stocked collectible card shops. Security footage captured the entire incident, giving Cary police investigators the visual evidence they needed to identify and apprehend the suspects with remarkable speed. That swift police work is exactly the kind of law enforcement response that communities across America need and deserve — criminals acting boldly and getting caught just as boldly.

Security footage captured the smash-and-grab in full — within days, Cary police had their suspects in custody and most of the $45,000 in stolen cards back in hand.