Outgoing New York City Fire Commissioner Robert S. Tucker is speaking out just days after resigning from his post, making it clear that Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani’s rhetoric and ideology played a key role in his decision to step down. Tucker, who submitted his resignation only one day after Mamdani won the election, told CBS News that the incoming mayor’s comments undermined his ability to continue serving in such a senior leadership position.

Tucker explained that the strain was not merely political but deeply personal, noting that his experience as a Jewish New Yorker significantly influenced his decision. While he kept his remarks measured, the divide between the two men was unmistakable. “Ideologically, there’s no doubt that the mayor and I disagree on some very fundamental things to me,” Tucker said, suggesting that Mamdani’s worldview represented a sharp break from the values and trust necessary for leading one of the city’s most vital public-safety institutions.

His resignation adds to growing concerns among New Yorkers—especially Jewish communities—about the direction the city may take under Mamdani, who has built his political identity around positions that have alienated many first responders, pro-Israel residents, and communities seeking stability and safety. Tucker’s departure underscores a profound shift within city leadership, raising questions about morale inside the FDNY and whether political ideology will overshadow public safety in the coming administration.

As the city prepares for a new mayor, Tucker’s warning stands as a sobering reminder: leadership at the highest levels must unite, not divide, the people who keep New Yorkers safe.