Tucker Carlson, a prominent conservative commentator and former Fox News host, has ignited a storm of controversy after declaring in an interview with far-right figure Nick Fuentes that he “dislikes Christian Zionists more than anybody” and labeling their beliefs as “Christian heresy.”

The statement has sent shockwaves through the conservative movement, particularly among evangelical Christians and pro-Israel advocates who have long viewed Carlson as a cultural ally. His remarks were framed as part of his broader critique of neoconservative foreign policy — a position he has maintained since the Iraq War — but his explicit rejection of Christian Zionism struck a nerve with a key segment of his audience.

Christian Zionism, a theological and political movement rooted in the belief that modern Israel fulfills biblical prophecy, has historically been one of the most influential forces shaping U.S. policy toward the Jewish state. According to a 2021 Pew Research survey, 82% of white evangelical Protestants view the establishment of Israel as vital to biblical prophecy, a conviction that has translated into strong political advocacy for Israel across Republican administrations — including that of President Donald Trump.

Under the Trump administration, the U.S.–Israel relationship reached historic heights. Trump recognized Jerusalem as Israel’s capital, moved the U.S. embassy there, and brokered the Abraham Accords — peace agreements between Israel and several Arab nations. Many evangelical Christians and Jewish Americans credited these moves as tangible fulfillment of a pro-Israel vision grounded in faith and national security.

Carlson’s disparagement of that worldview has drawn sharp rebukes from conservative and religious leaders. Pastor John Hagee, founder of Christians United for Israel, has long described Christian Zionism as “a biblical commandment, not a political preference.” Political analysts warn that Carlson’s rhetoric risks alienating millions of evangelical voters who view unwavering support for Israel as both a moral duty and a cornerstone of America’s role in the Middle East.

While Carlson has often distanced himself from interventionist policies, his latest comments appear to conflate theological conviction with foreign policy doctrine — a stance critics argue undermines America’s long-standing alliance with Israel. Supporters of Israel emphasize that Christian Zionism has been instrumental in fostering bipartisan support for the Jewish state, transcending policy divisions and reinforcing the U.S.–Israel bond on moral and strategic grounds.

For many within the pro-Israel community, Carlson’s words represent not just a theological dispute but a political betrayal. As the Middle East remains volatile and Israel faces growing international pressure, Carlson’s denunciation of one of its most steadfast constituencies could deepen divisions within the conservative movement at a time when unity is most needed.