The Manhattan subway system is once again under scrutiny after a violent career criminal was indicted for shoving an off-duty NYPD officer onto the L train tracks at Union Square. Authorities say the suspect, 28-year-old Aaron Walker, carried out the unprovoked attack on September 24, 2025, pushing a 24-year-old officer onto the rails just moments before an incoming train.

Walker, who is homeless and has a lengthy record of 17 prior arrests, was charged with attempted murder following a grand jury indictment announced on November 26 by Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg. Prosecutors revealed that Walker had been released from supervision only two days before the assault—despite having a recent history of random violence on the subway system, including slugging a stranger on the tracks earlier this year.

According to police sources, Walker fled the scene after the attack but was apprehended shortly afterward. The off-duty officer survived thanks to fast action from bystanders and MTA personnel, who alerted train operators and helped pull him out before the next train entered the station.

The case has reignited fierce debate over New York City’s bail reform policies and the growing challenge of managing repeat offenders within the transit system. NYPD data shows a 15% rise in recidivism-linked violent subway crimes from 2023 to 2024, a trend many officers and commuters say reflects an increasingly dangerous environment underground.

Walker’s history illustrates the core issue: despite a long pattern of aggression, including prior subway assaults, he continued to cycle in and out of the system with minimal restrictions. Critics argue that the latest incident demonstrates the failure of current policies to protect the public and hold chronic offenders accountable.

As Walker awaits trial on attempted murder charges, the attack has renewed calls from law enforcement and city leaders for stricter penalties, stronger supervision, and a renewed focus on restoring safety across New York’s transit network.