In a stunning escalation of his recent anti-Israel rhetoric, Tucker Carlson is now attacking not only Israel itself, but the millions of American Christians who stand with the Jewish state. After declaring, “stop talking about Israel, I don’t care about Israel at all,” Carlson launched into a theological tirade claiming “there is no longer a chosen people” and asserting that only those who “choose Jesus” are chosen by God.

Carlson accused pro-Israel Christians—who make up the largest base of Israel supporters in the United States—of promoting what he called a “Christian heresy,” arguing that God no longer has a covenant with the Jewish people and dismissing the biblical foundation that has united Jews and Christians for centuries.

His narrative ignores thousands of years of Judeo-Christian teaching affirming God’s enduring covenant with Israel, a belief clearly supported in both the Hebrew Scriptures and the New Testament. For millions of Christians, supporting Israel is not about ethnicity or “DNA,” as Carlson claims, but about honoring God's promises, standing with a democratic ally, and recognizing the shared spiritual heritage at the heart of Western civilization.

By dismissing Israel outright and lecturing Christians on theology, Carlson is not defending Christianity—he is undermining unity between faith communities that historically strengthened Western values, religious freedom, and moral clarity. His rhetoric plays directly into the hands of those who seek to delegitimize Israel and fracture the U.S.–Israel alliance.

Under President Trump, America embraced this partnership more strongly than ever, advancing the Abraham Accords, moving the U.S. Embassy to Jerusalem, and reaffirming Israel's right to defend itself. Carlson’s attempt to sever that connection represents a sharp departure from the values that have held conservatives together.

Calling millions of faithful Christians “heretical” for supporting Israel is not bold commentary—it is divisive and historically illiterate. Israel remains central to the Judeo-Christian foundation of the West, and attempts to erase that covenant only weaken the very civilization Carlson claims to defend.